Richard Sprague

Food Experiment: Good Idea Drink

How well does a new soda help prevent my glucose spikes?

Good Idea®

Good Idea®, “the Swedish sugar buster”, is a sparkling soft drink formulated with a proprietary blend of ingredients that claims to lower overall glucose levels when consumed before a meal. How well does it work for me?

My can of Good Idea: “The Swedish Sugar Buster”

My Personal Science Experiment

Wearing a Freestyle Libre™ continuous glucose monitor (CGM) on five different mornings on an empty stomach, I ate a bowl of Cream of Wheat mixed with 1/4 cup heavy cream and 1 TBS butter. This meal is about 500 calories, including 50g of net carbs and 35g of fat. I wanted a food that is generally considered “healthy”, with no sugar content, but high carb. I served it with a generous amount of fat to avoid significant glucose spikes.

I finished within five minutes and then I remained as sedentary as possible for the next two hours.

Instant Cream of Wheat is a high carb meal, which I loaded with extra fat

On one of those mornings I drank a can of Good Idea® fifteen minutes before the meal.

Show the code
## In the code above (not shown):
## We pull the glucose data into r_glucose
## and the metadata into r_notes

if(require(cmgr)){devtools::install_github("personalscience/cgmr")}

cgm_data <- cgmr:::cgm_data(r_glucose,r_notes)
foodname <- "Cream of Wheat"
# return all users who ate foodname
food_results_a <- cgmr::food_times_df(cgm_data,
                                    user_id = 1234,
                                    foodname = foodname)

food_results <- food_results_a %>% group_by(meal) %>% arrange(t) %>% mutate(value = value - first(value)) %>% ungroup() %>% arrange(meal)

new_foodnames <- c("Cream of Wheat (Plain)", "Cream of Wheat (Plain)", "Cream of Wheat (Goodidea)")


food_results[food_results$meal=="1234-8/31-Cream of Wheat","meal"] <- "Cream of Wheat (Plain) #1"

food_results[food_results$meal=="1234-9/2-Cream of Wheat","meal"] <- "Cream of Wheat (w/GoodIdea)"

food_results[food_results$meal=="1234-9/1-Cream of Wheat","meal"] <- "Cream of Wheat (Plain) #2"
food_results[food_results$meal=="1234-9/5-Cream of Wheat","meal"] <- "Cream of Wheat (Plain) #3"
food_results[food_results$meal=="1234-9/8-Cream of Wheat","meal"] <- "Cream of Wheat (Plain) #4"
Show the code
food_results %>% group_by(meal) %>% arrange(t) %>% mutate(value = value - first(value)) %>% ungroup() %>% arrange(meal) %>% #transmute(t,value,meal = paste(foodname,date_ch)) %>%
  ggplot(aes(x=t,y=value, color = meal)) +
      geom_rect(aes(xmin=0,
                xmax=120, #max(Date),
                ymin=-Inf,
                ymax=Inf),
            color = "lightgrey", 
            alpha=0.005) +
geom_line(linewidth=3) +
  labs(title = "Change in Glucose Levels", subtitle =  sprintf("%s",foodname), y = "Change in mg/dL", x = "Minutes") + 
  # ylim(-50,100)+
  psi_theme

This chart shows an obvious spike soon after plain Cream of Wheat meals, climbing at least 20 points within the first half hour. (Note: the values here are normalized so all meals start at 0). By contrast, the meal that followed a glass of Good Idea® seemed more stable.

Interestingly, in several of the plain meals, my glucose level was actually lower at the end than at the beginning, a “sugar crash” after eating such a high carbohydrate load. Good Idea®, on the other hand, gave no such crash.

Show the code
food_results %>%
    distinct() %>%
    group_by(meal, foodname) %>%
    summarize(
        iAUC = cgmr::auc_calc(tibble(time = t, value = value)),
        # auc = DescTools::AUC(t,value-first(value)),
        min = min(value),
        max = max(value),
        rise = last(value) - first(value),
        .groups = "drop"
    ) %>%
    select(-foodname) %>%
    {
        colnames(.) <- c("Experiment", "IAUC", "Min", "Max", "Rise")
        .
    } %>%
    # summarize(auc = sum((lag(value)-value)*(t-lag(t)), na.rm = TRUE)) %>%
    arrange(IAUC) %>%
    kable(digits = 0) %>%
    kableExtra::kable_styling(bootstrap_options = c("striped", "hover", "condensed"))

iAUC is a standard method that nutrition scientists use to calculate the overall effect of glucose changes. “Incremental Area Under the Curve” uses a simple sum of the area of all the trapezoids under the curve marked out by the various CGM measurements.

Conclusions

With such a small sample, we can’t say definitively but the relatively small rise on the day I drank the Good Idea® points to some effect.

Show the code
DBI::dbDisconnect(con)

More

For more details about this experiment, plus others that I write about weekly, subscribe to this free weekly newsletter:

HealthPersonal Science

Keep reading

Biohacking and Shifting Science

Exploring the historical and contemporary shifts in scientific paradigms, and the phenomenon of biohacking.

Get Your Shots!

If you're pro vaccine,shouldn't you want as many as possible?

How ProdromeGlia™ Affects my OpticareAI Cognitive Risk Score

How does a plasmalogen supplement affect my cognition?

Search